Copyright
Salt Lake Tribune May 4, 2003
It's easy to love the outlaw myth. Since Robin Hood defied the tyranny of
King John and the local sheriff, colorful characters who lived outside the law
have stolen our hearts and imaginations. Unfortunately, the noble outlaw is
mostly a myth. The most notorious Western felons, such as Jesse James, were
cold-blooded killers, and Billy the Kid makes today's nastiest street punk look
like a cupcake. The men who rode Utah's outlaw trail were a cut above your typical Western
gunslinger. Consider Willard Erastus Christiansen, who was born in Ephraim in
1864 and became the Last of the Bandit Riders. Like most Mormon farm boys, Christiansen didn't like farming, but he only
took to the wrong side of the law when the town bully tried to steal his girl.
He beat the bully's head until it felt soft and inaccurately feared he had
killed him. The bully's brother Moroni started yelling for the marshal.
Christiansen hit the road for Brown's Hole, a famous resort on the Outlaw Trail
that ran from Canada to Mexico, with major stopovers in Wyoming and Utah's
badlands. Christiansen went to work for Jim Warren, a rancher whose "main
business was hunting horses and cattle that didn't happen to be branded." After learning his trade on the ranges where Wyoming, Colorado and Utah
came together -- "Rustling was natural in this kind of country" --
Christiansen bought a ranch at Diamond Mountain. At his first showdown, he put a
bullet through Polito, a Mexican gunslinger who had stolen his horse --
"This stuff about 'em being sneaks and cowards ain't so," he recalled
-- and then rode 20 miles to get a doctor. Polito stayed at Willie's ranch while
he recovered. Along the trail Christiansen became Matt Warner, horse trader and stock
raider, gunfighter, railroad and bank robber, highwayman, convict, justice of
the peace and writer. Christiansen's older sister Tennie married Tom McCarty,
which didn't help him keep on the straight and narrow. Doc McCarty's boys --
Tom, Bill and George - - started Utah's outlaw tradition from their ranches near
the La Sal Mountains. Warner's criminal career started with a staged "fake" holdup
with Elza Lay and picked up momentum with a robbery in St. Johns, Ariz. A posse
almost caught Warner and his partner, who only escaped using "a trick that
was practiced regular by cowboy outlaws in them days" -- leaving fresh
horses along their escape route. "It worked nearly every time." Between 1889 and 1892, Warner's career heated up. He robbed banks in
Denver, Telluride, and Roslyn, Wash., of some $71,000, about $1.35 million in
today's cash. The law imprisoned Warner after he killed two men in self- defense in
Vernal. Gov. Heber Wells became intrigued with his case and pardoned him in
1900. Warner swore to go straight and apparently arranged a meeting with his pal
Butch Cassidy and Wells, who concluded Cassidy wasn't wanted for anything in
Utah and didn't need pardoning. Warner became Carbonville's justice of the peace and ran for sheriff of
Carbon County on the Bull Moose ticket in 1912. Historian David Norman noted he
would have been elected had he run as Matt Warner, but nobody had heard of
Willard Christiansen. "Warner won the love of all Carbon County, except the lawyers and
stuffed shirts," E Clampus Vitus memorialized.
"He was strictly a man of the people." Warner's classic memoir, "Last of the Bandit Riders," appeared
in (of all places) Cosmopolitan magazine in 1938, and he died soon after. He
left out the best parts of the story to protect his old comrades and publicly
insisted Butch Cassidy died in Argentina. But did he? Thereby hangs a tale.